[First presented
in teleconference with the University of Iowa, Center for the Book,
June, 1999]
The Book, the Page, the Text,
and Biblio-Futures
or, The Once and Future Book
Martin Irvine
Founding Director, Communication, Culture, and Technology
Program
Georgetown University
Major Themes:
-
The social meaning of the codex book.
-
The page and the book as an information system: 9th century manuscripts to
digital media.
-
The prehistory of hypertext and recent history of hypermedia as means
of transcending the material limits of the book.
-
The digital future of the book: possible book futures and scenarios
for etext.
The materiality of the medium, or
what exactly is the medium's message?
-
Books have a material history, writing and texts assigned value in the
physical form of books. The social significance of the book is under revision
in digital environment.
-
The material counterpart of textuality is codicity--the significance,
value, authority of the codex book from script to print and now digital
form.
-
The ideology of the book is sustained by a network of social and political
institutions--schools, literacy, publishing industry, copyright law, social
class expectations.
-
The book has always embodied technology and convergence in technology:
the old technologies of the book are usually transparent to us as technology
(part of the ideology of the book): the printed codex, and print technology
in general, seems "natural" to us.
-
Beware of technological determinism (McLuhan, Ong, Postman, Birkerts, etc.)
-
Regis Debray and Mediology: materiality, culture, technology, ideology
-
Information in the medium: cultural/social information in the material
form of the codex book, its use and reception throughout history.
The
Text as social node: "codicity" and "textuality"
-
Book as material form or instantiation of a text vs. text as weave of language
separable.
-
Book as nodal point, node in a network of texts and other material books.
Any book is always already a node, not simply a delimited object.
-
The abstract and material texts:
-
The abstract text of editors and the abstract text of literary theory.
-
Text has been dematerialized, abstracted from a necessary material bookness,
since modern printing.
-
Renaissance printing still linked to "codicity" (the material union of
text, type, page, and book).
-
On one level, the text has always been a node in a network, a momentary
configuration of language, genres, styles.
-
The digital abstraction of the text for multiple material channels of representation,
display, and design is only a step in the cultural logic of "mechanical
reproduction" as described by Walter Benjamin.
-
Modern notions of the pure, authentic text without embedding in accrued
commentary or anything that is not the "authors": why do these ideas seem
transparent or natural?
-
Modern notions of the text and the book are embedded in notions of authorship,
ownership, property, and book as commodity.
-
The "book" is always already a social, political, and economic entity before
its material form, but it is the material form of the book that supports,
encodes, and reproduces the nexus of forces that define it.
-
The "book" never has, and never will be, a simple or unified self-disclosing
material object in and of itself.
Semiology of the Page: the Page
as Information System
-
Modern books and digital media design are still post-medieval, or "post-codical".
-
Example: script and type fonts encode value and social meaning; there is
a politics of script and type (see Morrison, The Politics of Script).
-
For example, consider the semiology of type fonts:

-
There is a larger semiology of the page that was part of the literacy of
the manuscript book.
-
The Page as information system: the page contains an abundance of cultural
information beyond the text content.
-
Format and layout of the page as information system.
|
Medieval
|
Modern
|
Digital hypermedia
|
| Columns of text in various layouts. |
Columns of text in standardized layouts. |
Columns of text imitating print, with new variations in the space of
the screen. |
| Text often embedded in commentary or interpretative matrix. |
Text usually purified of anything not produced by the author or owner
of the text. |
Hypertext linking and variable page design allow for multiple interpretive
matrices. |
| Text and illustrations often interlinked and inseparable from
the design and idea of the book. |
Photography and illustration ordinarily separable from text. Most books
are text only. |
Multimedia assumed to be part of the design of the whole. |
| Hierarchies of script |
Hierarchies of type |
Hierarchies maintained but field of possibilities greatly enlarged |
| Center and margins as part of the signifying space of the page: margins
as space for expanding the text. |
Center and margins maintained as essential to book design and boundaries
enforced. |
Where's the center? Where's the margin? |
| Text and 2-D images only. |
Text and 2-D images only. |
Video, audio, text, graphics integrated in one interface or display
device. |
| Variation in text from copy to copy. Page includes non- "authorial"
texts, commentary, embedding in cultural library outside the book. "Hypertext"
links to commentary. |
Normalization and standardization of texts. Expectation of no
variation from copy to copy. Page normally displays nothing that is not the "author's". |
Variation and dynamic change in page contents. Texts changeable. Unstable
sense of document or text. Multiple authors on a "page". Hypermedia links
beyond any displaying text. |
Hypertext before hypertext:
cultural
attempts to transcend the physical limits of the book from manuscripts to digital
media
[Click on images for larger size]
 |
 |
 |
| 10th c., Donatus, Ars grammatica |
14th c., scribe laying out page |
10th c., Vergil plus Servius as gloss |
-
Attempts to reveal the network of the node, the text in its library, the
archive in the text.
-
Medieval "text and gloss" format, institutionalized in scriptoria and libraries
from c.800-1500.
-
Institutionalization of late classical page design for wider reproduction
-
Institutionalization of teaching, reading, and library practices in the
design of the page.
-
Reading and teaching experience embedded in received interpretations of
the text that point to a cultural library.
-
Text insufficient, non-self-disclosing; internal meaning displayed/displaced
in margins.
-
Space on page attempts to overcome some of the material limits of the represented
text.
-
Latin as operating system, page design as display device.
 |
 |
 |
| 12th c. glossed bible |
12th c glossed bible |
15th c. printed Decretals glossed |
Renaissance
and Early Modern Books:
Imagining Hypertext, or Beyond the Material Boundaries
of Books
- Reading wheel (image right), from Agostino Ramelli, Le diverse et artificiose
machine del Capitano Agostino Ramelli [The
various and ingenious machines of Captain Agostino Ramelli],
Paris, 1588. Wikipedia article.
- Science and the Artists' Book: Smithsonian Online Exhibition
- Attempts to move beyond the physical limits of books: reading wheel, text
in embedded commentary retained until 18th century.
-
Manuscript book properties reappearing in digital form: print only fixed
manuscript codicity in a single, standardized form.
-
Renaissance imitation of medieval books: the content of a new medium is
the immediately prior medium (McLuhan).
- Trithemius and
the ambiguity of the printed book as cultural memory system:
- He undertook to recopy printed
books on paper back into parchment manuscripts because manuscripts could
be trusted for lasting over time.
- One of the earliest cryptographers, obsessed with writing and permanence.
- See John Tolva, "The
Heresy of Hypertext: Fear and Anxiety in the Late Age of Print."
The "book" in the digital, networked
media environment
-
The book is of course now subsumed in digital media forms, but digital text now
transcends the material limits of the codex.
- The Web and Internet are still full of "book metaphor" that are irrelevant
to the digital medium: Web "pages", "files", etc.
-
E-Text and web hypermedia now the current format for many genres: digital
encyclopedias have now replaced books, many texts easier to use in digital
form.
-
The digital book: new memory and display devices for portability and storage.
-
The E-Book: preserving codicity and copyrightable object in the digital age: ebooks.com.
- What about "digital paper" and the multiple media formats for delivering
and displaying "books"?
- Amazon.com, Google, and the book: what is a book for Amazon and Google?
Bibliography on the Semiotics of the Early Book
- Martin Irvine, The Making of Textual Culture. Cambridge University
Press, 1994. Amazon.com
info.
Martin
Irvine
Copyright 1999-2006; rev. 10.22.2006 |